So Convenient to Ignore Our Soldiers These Days


I just wanted to write what will hopefully read as a friendly reminder that our veterans are our concern too. We don’t stop to think about that anymore. It’s not a public holiday like it once was, military service being something that a small percentage of the population is touched by, we are comfortable with our disconnect from the wars that we are constantly fighting. Service has become something of caste system, and war, continuous though distant, has become something we can all ignore.

This holiday has different meaning for me because I come from a long line of soldiers. People that I know fought because they loved so much. My generation has talked of soldiers and our military as if it glorifies violence. I am sure there are people in our armed forces who enjoy killing, there are sociopaths everywhere (CEOs, anyone) but the vast majority do it because of their love for something and their desire to take part in the American dream.

We’ve gotten rid of the draft and have a professional military and now we don’t have mass protests against our foreign adventures. We feel comfortable in some circles demonizing soldiers because “they have a choice” but every time I look at a social institution and see such disproportionality like our military I start getting suspicious of how much free choice we actually have. The professionalized military has allowed an elite to feel like their hands are clean of their choices. Like mob bosses, they can send someone in to do their dirty work for them and maintain the image of civility. I have a huge problem with this because it absolves the individuals responsible for our foreign actions and places the blame on people who don’t deserve it. It makes the elites (myself included) a bunch of cowards who never have to really stand by the courage of their convictions.

There are causes and people I would die for. I hope I never get asked to do that, but most of our poor is asked to do that on a daily basis in some capacity or another. If its not to fight wars, it is to survive with their dignity intact and their children safe in areas that we made unsafe. It’s a level of intensity that I feel and people I know with privilege don’t have and it is part of what makes me a little cagey. But it also makes me very conscious, aware and alive.

We seem to have a social structure that is engineered to make sure that the elites never face the consequences of their actions and as the last few years of the recession have that us, that is incredibly dangerous. I was told as a kid that in America, if you work hard and are talented, you can succeed, that we have a democratic meritocracy built to reward people for their work. I was told that if my family was poor it was our fault because we didn’t work hard enough. Never has the system been so rigged. I see it in the drug wars. I heard countless people at Stanford blame poor kids for bad choices only to watch them do drugs and be bailed out by mom and dad. People asked me why the poor have children so young and then no one batted an eye if a girl got pregnant in college and needed an abortion.

The same people that are happy to say that the failures of the poor schools reside on the backs on the students and parents and teachers, are the same people who never allow their child to be treated like criminals and who have the cultural capital to ensure that their kids get kind treatment all of their lives. The same people who defend Brock Turner, and this is literally the only time I’ve seen the rich claim to believe in restorative justice, are the same people that allow girls to be sold. Sometimes I feel like there is such a giant gap between the rich and the poor that we are no longer a society or a democratic community. We are leading parallel lives, no longer part of one American culture. As an American, especially as one who has watched so many people sacrifice for their country it breaks my heart.

So it is time for us to start counting our warriors as part of the social justice causes. This is becoming ever more important when the government looks to be gearing up for war to shore up support for this administration. Don’t let them divide us.


2 comments on “So Convenient to Ignore Our Soldiers These Days”

  1. aside from “the great compression” after 1945 (and the events from wec 1929-end of ww2) leading up to it, you have not had one american culture exactly because of the class differences. living aside one another. examples of that go back to the early 20th century (the city as social laboratory f.e. or take the whole chicago school of sociology with the “to see life” attitude)

    we agree on this topic freck society myths, btu then again think of what the US would look like if you did not have that myth of meritocracy.


  2. Has it ever occurred to you that I actually know more about American history and culture than you do, since you know I have to teach it and I have studied it? I am aware of the differences between the historical periods, but that is not a sufficient excuse for what is happening. It is easy to say from afar, oh isn’t this a curious social structure but that is not good enough for me. And actually, the period we are in right now has greater inequality than just about every other period in American history. Our supposed heyday in America happened when we had the least amount of inequality. So we know what is required to make things better and yet we choose not to do it. The point of studying history is to have broad-ranging view of different events and apply those to society so that you can better understand and improve conditions. I love you, but I am getting sick of you trying to mansplain on my own blog. I know just as much of the history as you do. I don’t care. We need to do better. Its easy for a non-American citizen to just say: oh well, isn’t that intellectual curious, but that doesn’t mean it can’t and shouldn’t be different. From now on you need to assume that I know what I am talking about or else my next blog post is going to be about the ways that nearly every 25 year old male tries to explain things to me that I already know like I am an idiot. I am not sure why this has been such a trend in the next week. You know, actually that is happening. That blog post will be happening tomorrow.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s